Howdy!
I've only logged 24 dives, but I can say that in my limited experience my navigation has gotten better and better with practice.
I paticularly love night diving, and am usually diving in Lake Mead with low vis ....
It would have been easy to fall into, "I'll just let my buddy make sure we get back" as he is a much more experienced diver than I am, but the pin in his compass broke, and the loaner he was using had Little itty bitty numbers that he could barely see, especially at night -- so I got my practice! Each time I did better than the time before. The last time we dove at night, I brought us up right in front of his truck parked on the shore!
Some days it "clicks", but others, it seems I'm always off course no matter how I try.
I have to say it's encouraging to read the other posts on this thread, from the folks with MUCH more experience than me!
thanks for posting!