People have been discussing the merits of these magazine equipment evaluations for years , specifically whether or not they are slanted in favor of their advertisers' products. I don't know how true that is, and it doesn't matter much to me, I just enjoy the articles. And the cute women in neoprene.
If I want product evaluations I ask divers I know and trust who are actually using the stuff. That's where boards like this can really pay off.